The Arlington House
Reviews


Menus

Reviews

Recipes
Wine List Directions Home

Times Union - Sunday, May 1, 2005
By William M. Dowd, Associate editor

Arlington House making its very own history

The proprietors of the old hotel in West Sand Lake would be proud of what has happened to their enterprise.

Chef Edward Murray, who with wife Carol opened the Arlington House four and a half years ago in the historic building in this Rensselaer County village, presides over a kitchen that turns out a stream of continually surprising, constantly pleasing dishes best described as a fusion menu.

Touches of Asia, Europe and the New World are provided by such ingredients as sticky rice, wasabi, cippolini, sugar cane and apples.

The building was the busy Arlington Hotel when it opened in the late 19th century, the last stop on a trolley line that then ran from the more populous towns to the west.

Over the years, the structure served a variety of purposes, most notably a 16-year-run as the Old Journey's End restaurant, named in honor of the trolley line.

The Murrays' renovation segmented the interior into several dining areas, decorated with smart wallpaper, refinished narrow plank floors and period art reproductions. A comfy bar has become a spot for a coterie of regulars and semi-regulars who drop in for a drink and some light fare from the tavern menu that ranges from small-bites to specialty pizzas. The deck they added is now open for the season.


Arlington House
3532 Route 43
West Sand Lake
12196
674-1880

Cuisine: American
Style: Country inn
Ambience: 19th-century country hotel, full bar, professional and attentive service
Rating: ***
Hours: Tuesday - Friday 4:30 to 9 p.m.; Sunday (September - May) 4 to 8 p.m.
Price: $$$
Price rating based on rough average of entree costs: $ for $9.95 and less; $$ or $15.95-$10.95; $$$ for $15.95 and higher.

Chef Murray, a native of nearby Wynantskill, worked in various local restaurants and earned a degree at Johnson & Wales University in Providence, R.I. An externship followed in the Florida Keys, as well as various other jobs, including corporate chef work in New York. He also was sous chef at the now-defunct four-diamond Ashley's at the Marriott in Colonie.

Constant Companion and I visited on a quiet weeknight, often not the best time for chefs who thrive in a bustling atmosphere but are easily distracted when not much is going on. Murray was up to the task.

Over Maker's Mark Manhattans and a basket of warm bread, we checked out the imaginative menu with the help of a few explanations from Melissa, our personable server. Companion began with the shrimp scampi Berardi, a trio of plump shrimp wrapped in prosciutto, grilled and served with a classic mornay sauce -- butter, milk or cream, chardonnay, seasonings and cheese (without the cheese it's a bechamel). A rich and scrumptious beginning.

I'd pondered the clams and mussels cioppino and the General Tso's chicken, then decided on the escargot volauvent. I chose correctly, being served a generous number of tender snails in a classic, savory Provencal-style sauce with a puff pastry base. An excellent way to keep the aromatic sauce from flowing away, and a nice counterpoint to the escargot.

Our entrees measured up to the starters, from eye appeal to taste.

My pork schnitzel was a trio of flattened, breaded pork cutlets sauteed tender and served with braised red cabbage and a cream sauce dotted with slices of Granny Smith apple and caramelized onions.

This is a nice takeoff on a German standard, the apple and onion pairing one of my favorite sweet-and-sour combinations with sauteed meats. Smooth mashed potatoes and a little stack of gently grilled vegetables completed the generous tableau that pushed me into a take-home bag request.

Companion's seafood special was a fish of a different color, literally. Grilled tuna and escolar were the centerpiece of the offering, both cooked precisely as ordered. She loved the tuna, but wasn't thrilled with the escolar. That's not an uncommon reaction to escolar, sometimes known as rudderfish.

It has a heavy fat content, so Murray's decision to grill it was a wise one. But anyone with a sensitive digestive system usually is advised to steer clear of escolar and its high wax esters quotient that often makes it very difficult to digest.

The dessert list Melissa recited sounded too good to bypass. Companion was delighted with a cup of good decaf coffee and the thin-sliced chocolate pate, decorated with a cluster of raspberries and a bit of powdered sugar and drizzled with a raspberry coulis.

My s'mores creme brulee, decorated with a sliced, fanned strawberry, was from a recipe Murray created for the annual Girl Scout Cookie Cuisine competition held locally to promote the iconic snack. It continues to deserve the prize it won.

Our bill, as always before tip, was $93.

Metroland - Dining Guide - Spring/Summer 2002
Continental
Arlington House


Once the Arlington Hotel, this is a gorgeous-looking destination where seafood is especially well done and the menu is changed to fit each season. Good homemade desserts, too. Full bar.

Metroland - Best of the Capital Region 2001
Best New Restaurant
Arlington House

3532 Route 43, West Sand Lake

This former hotel is now known for its seafood, among other things, thanks to chef Rick Weber’s summers cooking in Nantucket. American fusion fare is offered, such as marinated grilled salmon with wasabi vinaigrette or pan-seared rainbow trout with a pancetta white wine butter sauce.

Times Union - Sunday, November 19, 2000
By William M. Dowd, Associate editor

A new journey to good taste

WEST SAND LAKE -- Edward and Carol Murray have embarked on a journey back to the future. The prospects appear bright.

In the late 19th century, the Arlington Hotel was a bustling establishment out here in the middle of Rensselaer County. It was the last stop -- No. 22 -- on the trolley line that ran from the more populous towns to the west.

It eventually ran its course, but in 1979 Carol Phillipi opened a restaurant there that she called the Old Journey's End, in honor of the trolley line. She operated it for 16 mostly successful years, but it then fell into an unhappy succession of incarnations until the Murrays came along.

Barely a month ago, they opened the Arlington House, honoring the original name, but with a wholesale renovation that has breathed life into the space, and segmented the interior into several dining areas.

Now, you'll find smart wallpaper and woodwork, freshly refinished narrow plank floors, a new bar and a small army of waitstaff keeping an eagle eye out for patrons' every need -- sometimes to the point of hovering.

Chef-owner Murray has parlayed his own wide-ranging experience with that of kitchen colleague Rick Weber to create an eclectic, imaginative menu perhaps best labeled American Regional.



Arlington House
3532 Route 43
West Sand Lake
12196
674-1880

Cuisine: American
Style: Country inn
Ambience: 19th-century country hotel, full bar, professional and attentive service
Rating: ****
Hours: 4:30 to 9 p.m. daily; closed Sunday.
Price: $$$
Price rating based on rough average of entree costs: $ for $9.95 and less; $$ or $15.95-$10.95; $$$ for $15.95 and higher.

Murray, a native of Wynantskill, worked in various local restaurants and earned a degree at Johnson & Wales University in Providence, R.I. An externship followed in the Florida Keys, as well as various other jobs, including corporate chef work in New York. He also was sous chef at the four-diamond Ashley's at the Marriott in Colonie. Now, he handles mostly the cold dishes -- salads, desserts and so on.

Weber moved over from Troy's well-regarded Allegro Cafe where he learned at the elbow of talented chef/owner Andrew Plummer. He has a certain affinity for seafood, perhaps a product of working on Nantucket for several summers.

I had been remarking to Constant Companion the other day that, with rare exceptions, the restaurant food in this area was becoming boring for a reviewer. Yes, there are some imaginative spots around, but in this line of work I can't keep going back to the same places.

One of the problems I've encountered has been a terrible sameness because so many people are buying so many of the same ingredients from the same purveyors and doing the same things with them.

It may make economic sense to pick up a jar of demi glace from Sysco, or a piece of fish from Captain Lee's, but it doesn't do a lot for the adventurous palate.

That's why the Arlington House menu was a pleasant surprise: a continually changing "trio of fishes"; a "fall melange" with ingredients changing depending on what the chefs find at the markets; rock shrimp and crab cake; duck stir fry. And a nice wine list to go with it, including a decent selection of New York state wines.

I began with the Shaker Oyster Broil, a half-dozen exceedingly tender oysters on the half-shell, doused with a heavenly herb cream, and dusted with cheese for an au gratin finish. A crisp corn relish made a nice counterpoint.

Constant Companion was surprised by the abundance of the house salad, a pile of young mesclun greens and veggies in a roasted onion/tarragon creamy dressing.

Mrs. Brown, history buff that she is, felt compelled to order the Stop Twenty-Two Pie, named for the old trolley schedule: a nice fall presentation of roasted chicken, vegetables and a garlic herb cream with a bit of puff pastry atop.

The entrees were a hit all around. Mrs. Brown had the fresh garlic and black conch pasta, mixed in with escargots, clams and tomatoes and basil with a splash of anisette. A brothy, full-flavored mixture.

Companion's grilled New York sirloin was a beautiful lean, medium-rare piece of steak with sauteed mushrooms and a garlic parsley buerre saucing that complemented the aged flavor of the meat.

My deep sea scallops were exquisite -- a generous amount of lightly cooked morsels with a sweet, robust tandori glaze, sided by a sweet pea basmati rice, a red cabbage slaw, corn relish, grilled peppers and more.

At the Arlington, the "more'' can mean up to a half-dozen different vegetables accompaniments because Weber and Murray insist on feeding the eyes as well as the mouth with cleverly designed presentations that avoid that old bugaboo of dishes being so heavily constructed they're difficult to eat.

We finished with excellent desserts -- a soup bowl of blueberry creme brulee for each of my companions, and a delicious chocolate pate construction with red raspberries for me.

The quality of ingredients here is just as evident as the talent in preparation. Asked about it later, Murray said:

"We're very picky about ingredients. Our game is fresh, we buy the whole veal leg and cut it down, we use classic reductions instead of buying ready-made. We even use five different purveyors for our meats. I don't know if it makes the best economic sense, but we want to serve the best we can."

So far, so good.

Our bill -- as always before tax, tip and alcohol -- was $97.85 for the three of us, or $32 and change each.



directNIC Search
Hosted by directNIC.com